What to Do With a Family Home After Inheriting It
What to Do With a Family Home After Inheriting It
Inheriting a family home can bring a mix of emotions—grief, nostalgia, and sometimes stress. While it may feel like a blessing, it also comes with important decisions that can significantly impact your finances and long-term plans.
Whether you're considering selling the inherited home, turning it into a rental, or moving in yourself, it’s important to understand the steps involved. From handling legal documents to navigating the PA probate process, every choice has legal, tax, and emotional consequences.
In this guide, we’ll walk you through everything you need to know about what to do with a family home after inheriting it. You’ll find practical estate property tips, expert advice, and clear steps to help you make the best decision for your situation.
1. Understand the Legal Process After Inheriting a Home
Before you make any decisions about the property, it’s important to understand your legal standing. Just because you’re named in a will—or expected to inherit—doesn’t mean you can immediately take control of the home.
What Happens Immediately After Death
The first step is to locate the will, if there is one. The will typically names an executor, who is responsible for managing the estate and ensuring that assets—including the home—are distributed according to the deceased’s wishes.
If there’s no will, the estate will go through intestate succession, a legal process where the state decides who inherits the property. This can vary depending on family structure and local laws.
Until the legal process is complete, you can't sell, rent, or renovate the home. Ownership must be legally transferred first.
The Role of Probate
The Role of Probate
Most inherited homes go through probate, a court-supervised process for validating the will, paying off debts, and distributing assets.
If you’re in Pennsylvania, you’ll need to understand the PA probate process, which typically includes:
Filing the will with the Register of Wills in the county where the deceased lived.
Getting official approval to act as executor or administrator.
Taking inventory of the estate, including real property.
Paying any outstanding debts and taxes before the home can legally change hands.
Probate can take several months, or even longer if the estate is complicated or contested. During this time, it’s important to maintain the property and keep records of any related expenses.
2. Navigating the PA Probate Process
If the inherited property is located in Pennsylvania, it must go through the PA probate process unless it was held in a trust or owned jointly with rights of survivorship. This legal process ensures that the decedent’s assets, including the home, are properly managed and distributed.
Steps in the Pennsylvania Probate Process
Understanding the basics can help you avoid delays and costly mistakes. Here’s what typically happens:
File the will with the Register of Wills in the county where the deceased lived. If there’s no will, you’ll begin the intestate process.
Petition the court to open probate and request appointment as executor (if named in the will) or administrator (if no will exists).
Notify heirs, creditors, and beneficiaries. Creditors usually have a set time—typically one year—to make claims against the estate.
Inventory and appraise all estate assets, including the home. This will help determine estate value and tax obligations.
Pay any debts, taxes, and fees from the estate’s funds before distributing assets. This may include property taxes, outstanding mortgage payments, or utility bills.
Distribute the remaining assets, including the family home, once all obligations are met.
Key Pennsylvania-Specific Rules and Deadlines
Pennsylvania Inheritance Tax: Heirs must pay a state inheritance tax, which ranges from 0% to 15% depending on the relationship to the deceased.
Probate fees are based on estate size and must be paid before assets can be transferred.
Executor compensation is allowed and may be negotiated or based on a percentage of the estate.
The whole probate process can take 9–12 months or longer if there are disputes or complications.
Navigating probate can feel overwhelming, but staying organized and understanding the PA probate process makes it more manageable—especially if you’re considering selling the inherited home later on.
3. Evaluate the Property’s Financial Situation
Evaluate the Property’s Financial Situation
Before you decide what to do with the inherited home, take a close look at its financial condition. Even if the house was paid off, there are still costs and obligations you’ll need to account for.
Outstanding Debts and Mortgage
Start by finding out if there’s still a mortgage or lien on the property. If the home has a mortgage, the lender must be notified of the owner’s passing. In most cases, the mortgage doesn’t disappear—it becomes the heir’s responsibility.
If the deceased had a reverse mortgage, you may need to repay the loan immediately to keep the property or sell it to settle the balance.
Be sure to:
Contact the lender to discuss options.
Avoid missing payments during probate to prevent foreclosure.
Property Taxes and Home Insurance
Even during the probate process, you’ll need to continue paying property taxes and keep the home insured. Make sure the insurance policy is updated to reflect the current ownership status.
Lack of proper coverage could leave the home vulnerable to damage or loss—and the estate liable for costs.
Maintenance and Ongoing Costs
Inherited homes often need repairs or updates, especially if they’ve been vacant or poorly maintained. Be prepared to cover:
Utilities (electricity, water, gas)
Lawn care or snow removal
Security or alarm system costs
These ongoing expenses can add up quickly, especially during a lengthy probate process. Understanding the true cost of keeping the property will help you decide whether selling the inherited home, renting it out, or moving in is financially realistic.
4. Decide What to Do With the Home
Decide What to Do With the Home
Once you've evaluated the legal and financial aspects, it's time to make a practical decision: what should you actually do with the inherited home? There’s no one-size-fits-all answer—it depends on your financial goals, emotional ties, and long-term plans.
Option 1: Move In
If you’re emotionally attached or in need of housing, moving into the inherited home might be the right choice.
Pros:
No need to search for new housing.
You keep the property in the family.
Cons:
You may need to refinance or assume the mortgage.
Maintenance and property taxes become your responsibility.
You may need to buy out other heirs if you’re not the sole inheritor.
Option 2: Rent It Out
Turning the property into a rental home can generate steady income while preserving ownership.
Things to consider:
Are you ready to be a landlord?
Will you manage the property yourself or hire someone?
Do you understand local rental laws and tax obligations?
This option works best if the property is in good condition and located in an area with strong rental demand.
Option 3: Sell the Inherited Home
In many cases, selling the inherited home is the most practical decision—especially if:
You don’t plan to live there.
You want to split proceeds with other heirs.
The cost of upkeep is too high.
Selling gives you liquidity and a clean break, but it can be an emotional process. You’ll need to prepare the home for sale, understand the tax implications, and navigate the real estate market. We’ll go deeper into this in the next section.
5. Tips for Selling an Inherited Home
Tips for Selling an Inherited Home
If you’ve decided that selling the inherited home is the best option, taking a strategic approach can save you time, reduce stress, and help you get the best return.
Get the Home Professionally Appraised
Start by hiring a certified appraiser to determine the current market value. This will help:
Set a competitive asking price.
Settle any disagreements among heirs.
Avoid underpricing or overpricing the home.
You may also want to consult a local real estate agent familiar with estate sales for a Comparative Market Analysis (CMA).
Clean, Declutter, and Make Repairs
Inherited homes are often filled with a lifetime of belongings. Take time to:
Sort through personal items—you might find documents or valuables.
Donate, store, or discard clutter to make the home more presentable.
Complete basic repairs like fixing leaks, painting walls, or updating fixtures.
A clean, move-in-ready home is much more attractive to buyers—and can fetch a higher price.
Understand the Tax Implications
Good news: when you inherit a home, your cost basis is typically “stepped up” to the home’s fair market value at the time of death. This can significantly reduce capital gains taxes when you sell.
For example, if your parents bought the home for $100,000 but it was worth $300,000 when you inherited it, and you sell it for $310,000—you’re only taxed on the $10,000 gain (not the full $210,000).
Still, it’s smart to consult with a tax advisor to understand how inheritance and sale proceeds will impact your taxes, especially if multiple heirs are involved.
Work With a Real Estate Agent Experienced in Estate Sales
Look for an agent who:
Understands the emotional aspects of selling a family home.
Knows the PA probate process and can coordinate with your estate attorney.
Has experience dealing with multiple heirs or out-of-state sellers.
Their expertise can make the sale faster, smoother, and less stressful.
6. Dealing With Multiple Heirs
Dealing With Multiple Heirs
When a family home is inherited by more than one person, the situation can quickly become complicated. Emotions run high, and it’s not uncommon for heirs to have different goals or expectations about what to do with the property.
Common Challenges With Co-Inherited Property
One heir wants to sell, another wants to keep the home.
Someone may want to move in, but can’t afford to buy out the others.
Disagreements over property value, repairs, or listing price.
Varying levels of emotional attachment to the home.
These differences can lead to tension—or even legal disputes—if not handled carefully.
Solutions to Consider
Open communication is key. Sit down with all parties and discuss options honestly. If emotions are getting in the way, you might consider hiring a mediator to guide the conversation.
Other solutions include:
Buyout: One heir purchases the others’ shares based on fair market value.
Sell and split the proceeds: Often the simplest and cleanest solution.
Set up a legal agreement: If renting the property, put clear terms in writing for how income and responsibilities are divided.
Legal Options if You Can’t Agree
If no resolution is possible, a co-owner can file a partition action, which forces the sale of the property through the courts. This should always be a last resort, as it’s costly, time-consuming, and can strain family relationships.
To avoid conflict, it’s smart to bring in a real estate attorney familiar with estate property tips and inheritance laws in Pennsylvania.
7. Tax Responsibilities of Inheriting a Home
Tax Responsibilities of Inheriting a Home
Inheriting a home comes with more than just memories and decisions—it also brings tax responsibilities. Understanding these ahead of time can help you avoid surprises and make smart financial choices.
Pennsylvania Inheritance Tax
If the home is in Pennsylvania, you’ll likely owe inheritance tax. The rate depends on your relationship to the deceased:
0% for a spouse.
4.5% for direct descendants (children, grandchildren).
12% for siblings.
15% for other heirs (like nieces, nephews, or friends).
The tax is based on the property’s value at the time of death and is usually due within nine months. However, you’ll get a 5% discount if you pay within three months.
Federal Capital Gains Tax
As mentioned earlier, when you sell an inherited home, you’ll typically benefit from a stepped-up basis. This means the home’s original purchase price is replaced with its market value on the date of death.
You’ll only owe capital gains tax on the difference between that stepped-up basis and the sale price—not the total amount it appreciated over time.
This rule can dramatically reduce your tax bill when selling the inherited home.
Property Tax Adjustments
Once the home is transferred into your name, expect a reassessment of property taxes, especially if the home has appreciated significantly. Some counties offer exemptions or deferments for inherited homes—check with your local tax office.
File the Right Tax Forms
You or the estate’s executor may need to file:
A PA inheritance tax return (Form REV-1500).
A federal estate tax return, if the estate exceeds the federal exemption limit.
A final income tax return for the deceased.
When in doubt, consult with a CPA or estate planning attorney who understands the PA probate process and estate tax laws.
8. Final Thoughts: Making the Right Decision for Your Family
Inheriting a family home is rarely simple—it’s a blend of emotional weight, legal responsibilities, and financial decisions. Whether you choose to keep the home, rent it out, or go forward with selling the inherited home, the best path is one that aligns with your family's goals and circumstances.
Take Your Time, But Don’t Delay Key Steps
Grief can cloud judgment, so give yourself space to process. However, don’t let that turn into inaction. Ignoring necessary steps—like maintaining the property, addressing taxes, or communicating with co-heirs—can lead to costly consequences.
Seek Professional Guidance
Navigating an inherited home, especially within the PA probate process, often calls for help from:
Estate attorneys
Certified public accountants (CPAs)
Real estate agents experienced in estate property sales
These professionals can help you make informed decisions, stay compliant with laws, and reduce your stress during an already difficult time.
Every Family—and Every Home—is Different
There’s no one right answer for everyone. A home that was once the heart of your family may now serve a different purpose. What matters most is making a decision that honors your loved one’s legacy while meeting your family’s current needs.
Whether that means creating new memories or turning the page, take comfort in knowing you're doing what’s best for the future.
Ready to Sell Your Inherited Home in Berks County?
At Prime Investments, we specialize in helping families like yours sell with confidence—without the stress or hassle. Whether you're dealing with probate or just want a fast, fair offer, Alex and Ashley are here to help every step of the way.
👉 Fill out our seller form to get started today. It only takes a minute—and it could be the first step toward peace of mind.
